BitDepthFeatured

The price of the single point of failure

3 Mins read

Above: Illustration by eamesBot/DepositPhotos

BitDepth#1420 for August 21, 2023

After TSTT’s network experienced widespread failures on August 09, the company issued general apologies about the issue, promising prompt restorative action.

It wasn’t until Communications Worker’s Union Secretary-General Clyde Elder accused the company of neglect and poor maintenance that CEO Lisa Agard responded with details on the reasons for the hours-long outage.

“A GE breaker at Nelson Exchange designed to function uninterruptedly for 30 years malfunctioned when there was an electrical surge,” Agard told the TT Guardian.

“This equipment is only eight years old. This led to a series of events which ultimately led to important telecommunications equipment not being supported by power.”

TSTT CEO Lisa Agard.

Reading directly from that statement, questions arise about the reference to a breaker, which isolates equipment from an electrical surge, and its implied role in impacting support systems which should have supplied redundant stored power, normally from an industrial UPS.

A request to discuss the technical details of the incident was ignored by TSTT, so what’s left is an admission of reliance on a single, probably expensive piece of equipment, which represented a point of failure that appears to have had no clear redundancies.

The problems that arise from a single point of failure are not unique to technology.

The concept was most dramatically illustrated by the story of Achilles, whose mother, according to mythology, dipped him in the River Styx, granting him immortality save for his heel, where she’d held him.

If there is any moral to be taken from this fanciful sidebar on the Trojan War, it is that the part of any system that is weakest and least replaceable will eventually suffer a catastrophic failure.

In February 2022, while the country was firmly under pandemic lockdown, a 21-metre-tall Palmiste tree, its bole rotted through with fungus infestation, came crashing down in Grant Trace, Rousillac.

The falling tree severed a single-phase TTEC 12 KV distribution line then hit the 220KV line circuit which transfers most of the power from Trinidad Generation Unlimited (TGU) to TTEC.

TGU generates one third of the country’s electricity and the sudden loss of that much capacity caused a cascading collapse of the grid shutting off electricity for more than twelve hours for most of Trinidad.

Six months later – again in Rousillac – a landslip caused the partial collapse of a 220 KV transmission tower, leading to load shedding and an outage for 30 per cent of the country, most in the south of Trinidad.

These are not mechanical failures, they are design problems, architectures with limited redundancy that made critical systems more fragile than they needed to be.

Ultimate redundancy is two of everything, but that’s both needlessly and prohibitively expensive.

Design thinking in networks, whether they carry electricity or data, is a measured consideration of the eventual failure of components and how their function can be replaced or rerouted with minimal impact on the end user.

Illustration by rudall30/DepositPhotos.com

It’s an idea that has wider relevance to society. Any company or government hierarchy that doesn’t have a proper succession plan is also courting the problems that result from a single point of failure.

Pandemic restrictions brought the importance of redundancy and resilience home, quite literally.

Having a secondary source of internet connectivity to support two remote teachers and a remote student at home became critical after Flow experienced an extended outage.

Keeping that internet connection going across electrical brownouts and outages with a UPS went quickly from luxury to necessity.

The contemplation of redundancy and efficiency in networks is a challenge even in small systems.

During a complete revamp of my desktop workstation, its peripherals and connections, a topological map of the system, freed from the tangle of wires and boxes, revealed a systemic problem.

I’d replaced both my workstation and laptop systems, both upgraded to 100base-T ports along the way, but the systems were connected using a 10base-T ethernet rated switch and cabling.

That simple, inexpensive change doubled throughput speeds, particularly useful since I move large files back and forth across that hardwired connection.

It would be a mistake to think about a single point of failure as being only technology related.

It’s a weakness of systems designed by humans, not a cruel whim of fate. A fragility in the heel of presumptions of robustness or invulnerability that are inadequately tested and believed to be more secure and protected than they actually are.

Finding and assessing these weaknesses is even more critical when continuous availability and access are the characteristic most highly prized in a system.

It’s why skydivers have a reserve parachute, but with every jump they hear the wind roaring past their ears and see the ground growing closer.
Their enthusiasm to design redundancy is commensurately more urgent in their planning before stepping through the door of an aircraft.

The state of Caribbean digital transformation

The state of Caribbean digital transformation

Despite 87 per cent believing that digital will disrupt their industry, 87 per cent acknowledged that they don't have the right leaders
Read More
The WordPress War

The WordPress War

WPEngine and the websites of its customers were blocked from the WordPress log-in system theme and plug-in updates and other background processes that enable a Wordpress website.
Read More
A budget of concrete and asphalt

A budget of concrete and asphalt

Four years after Hassel Bacchus took up the pioneering role of Digital Transformation Minister, the 2025 budget could not identify any completed transformation project that's positively affected citizens.
Read More
Arima’s first step toward becoming a smart city

Arima’s first step toward becoming a smart city

The public WiFi was officially activated on September 28 at the hospital, and it's fast. A local ping registered 250 megabits of download speed and 126 for upload.
Read More
Now hear this!

Now hear this!

Budget headsets will effectively dampen ambient sounds, but tend to be an all or nothing solution.
Read More
A taxing time for all

A taxing time for all

Tax collection began using the least customer-friendly interface imaginable, lines outside a government building.
Read More
Mobile devices, a war of increments

Mobile devices, a war of increments

Mixing and matching the two rival ecosystems is essentially impossible, so it's the utility of the products combined that makes the biggest difference.
Read More
Why cash is king in Trinidad and Tobago

Why cash is king in Trinidad and Tobago

In 2017, 16 per cent of users owned a credit card, a figure that dropped to 15 per cent by 2023.
Read More
I shopped at Temu!

I shopped at Temu!

Temu is great fun to explore and offers many bargains but product quality can be wildly variable.
Read More
What’s needed to make e-Governance happen?

What’s needed to make e-Governance happen?

“If we look at successful governments that have achieved a certain level in of success in these programs, some things stand out."
Read More
Changing the education conversation

Changing the education conversation

There are local schools that aspire to continuous improvement and others that struggle to make it through a working day without bloodshed.
Read More
Practical steps to reducing cybersecurity risks

Practical steps to reducing cybersecurity risks

The process, to be effective, must be ongoing and managed to ensure that vendors meet required standards.
Read More
The consequences of careless code

The consequences of careless code

The cruel reality of Crowdstrike is that it wasn't a cybersecurity attack. It was a quality of service lapse and the incident puts IT professionals in an odd space.
Read More
What leaders are doing to enable digital transformation

What leaders are doing to enable digital transformation

If people in your organisation are coming to you, telling you we need to change these things, you really should listen.
Read More
Apple’s photography workflow

Apple’s photography workflow

Every Apple device has a Photos database and every image that's taken with a mobile iOS device or imported into the desktop Photos app gets added to it.
Read More
An apathy of cybersecurity concerns

An apathy of cybersecurity concerns

It's weird when a definitive statement about the importance of cybersecurity comes from the people who broke into your digital house.
Read More
Putting data to work to improve perception

Putting data to work to improve perception

When it comes to the data, the numbers are there, but it also has to work alongside your goals.
Read More
The state of TT broadband, 2024

The state of TT broadband, 2024

In 2022, mobile internet penetration it had risen to 62.9 per 100 citizens, almost twice the penetration rate of fixed wireless.
Read More
Apple’s plan for device domination

Apple’s plan for device domination

Siri, at 13, gets an upgrade with Apple Intelligence, promising a significant upgrade on Siri’s smarts in a small language model that functions on device.
Read More
Adobe’s terms of disservice

Adobe’s terms of disservice

The activation servers for Adobe's CS, CS2 and CS3 products were shut down between 2013 and 2017. In May last year, Adobe stopped its customer support from deactivating perpetual licenses...
Read More
The state of Caribbean digital transformation The state of Caribbean digital transformation
The WordPress War The WordPress War
A budget of concrete and asphalt A budget of concrete and asphalt
Arima’s first step toward becoming a smart city Arima’s first step toward becoming a...
Now hear this! Now hear this!
A taxing time for all A taxing time for all
Mobile devices, a war of increments Mobile devices, a war of increments
Why cash is king in Trinidad and Tobago Why cash is king in Trinidad...
I shopped at Temu! I shopped at Temu!
What’s needed to make e-Governance happen? What’s needed to make e-Governance happen?
Changing the education conversation Changing the education conversation
Practical steps to reducing cybersecurity risks Practical steps to reducing cybersecurity risks
The consequences of careless code The consequences of careless code
What leaders are doing to enable digital transformation What leaders are doing to enable...
Apple’s photography workflow Apple’s photography workflow
An apathy of cybersecurity concerns An apathy of cybersecurity concerns
Putting data to work to improve perception Putting data to work to improve...
The state of TT broadband, 2024 The state of TT broadband, 2024
Apple’s plan for device domination Apple’s plan for device domination
Adobe’s terms of disservice Adobe’s terms of disservice

🤞 Get connected!

A once weekly email notification of new stories on TechNewsTT. Just that. No spam.

Possible UI Glitch. Click top right corner to dismiss 👉

Get Connected!

A once weekly email notification of new stories on TechNewsTT.

Just that. No spam.

Related posts
News Briefs

TSTT confirms Kent Western as CEO

1 Mins read
Effective October 01, 2024, TSTT has confirmed the appointment of Kent Western as Chief Executive Officer. Western has been acting…
Press Releases

TSTT partners with France's SOGET to improve port efficiency and digital transformation

3 Mins read
The PCS complements existing systems, neither replacing nor competing with them, ushering in a new aspect of interoperability and data sharing.
Press Releases

TSTT activates disaster plan, closes select outlets

1 Mins read
We are working closely with the Office of Disaster Preparedness and Management (ODPM), Tobago Emergency Management Agency (TEMA) and other agencies to ensure critical services are restored promptly and safely, if impacted.
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
dennise
1 year ago

Very thoughtful article. Love the story about your own workspace.

For 5 years @keitademming and I did summer camps for young people focussing on systems thinking and design thinking. We eventually abandoned the idea because of a lack of traction.

What I am taking away from this is that at the highest level of our corporations, design thinking is not part of the way we work. My question is what has to happen for us to transform our approach?

trackback
1 year ago

[…] Trinidad and Tobago – After TSTT’s network experienced widespread failures on August 09, the company issued general apologies about the issue, promising prompt restorative action… more […]

×
FeaturedTechnology Reporting

What caused the Internet failure of December seventh?

2
0
Share your perspective in the comments!x
()
x